Project:			1-6
Name of evaluator:		First name, last name
Format:				Is the report complete? If not, what is missing?

Use EPFL grading (1-6) for each section.

1. Overall architecture (Weight 2)
*************************************************
- Is it easy to read and understandable? 
- Explanation and justification of assumptions
- Are the most important elements of the system described?
- Mapping of functionality onto hardware and software components?
- Description of interaction between components (information flow)?
- Partitioning into levels (are the different parts on the right level of the pyramid?)?
- Constraints / Regulations?
- Source of information listed?


1.a Control system  (Weight 2)
*************************************************
- What are the requirements? (What needs to be monitored, regulated and controlled? How does this translate into requirements?)
- Is it easy to read and understandable?
- Explanation and justification of assumptions
- Which parts are continuous, which parts discrete? Why?
- Selection of PLCs/IO parts (suitable? explained? How many?)
- Source of information listed

1.b Communication architecture (Weight 2)
*************************************************
- What are the requirements?  (How much information, how frequent, how far? How many devices? What kind of latencies are acceptable? How does this translate into requirements?)
- Is it easy to read and understandable?
- Explanation and justification of assumptions
- Assignment of real-time / non -real time requirements
- Which parts are cyclic / event driven?
- Does protocol selection match requirements?
- Communication equipment (suitable? explained?)
- Synchronization
- Source of information listed

1.c SCADA (Weight 2)
*************************************************
- What are the requirements?
- Is it easy to read and understandable?
- Explanation and justification of assumptions
- Selection of HW (suitable? explained? How many?)
- Source of information listed

2. Supervision Tango part (Weight 2.5)
*************************************************
- List of signals to monitor and control complete and explained?
- List of alarms and priorities complete and justified?
- Architecture choices are described and justified
	- how many device servers are needed?
	- where do the device servers run?
	- what are the device servers connected to? through which protocol(s)?
- Are the HMI principles adhered to in the synoptic views?
- Does the device server work? I.e., can we run it?

3. Manufacturing Execution System (Weight 1)
*************************************************
- Are the purposes identified correctly?
- Is the proposed performance measure understandable and relevant?
- Are the dependencies and implications on the other layers identified and described?

4. FMEA / FTA (Weight 2.5)
*************************************************
- Is it easy to read and understandable?
- Explanation and justification of choice of method
- Explanation and justification of assumptions
- Source of information
- Completeness (are the most important elements of the analysis described?)


5. Presentation (Weight 2)
*************************************************
- Is it easy to follow?
- Do the slides support the presentation?


5. Choice
**********
- If you as a customer had to pick between this and the other project bid, which one would you choose and why?